Trying a new format for the written reviews, in the form of a report card. Feel free to let me know which method you prefer.
REPORT CARD
LEAVE NO TRACE
SUMMARY:
Grade F
|
This movie fails on every level. The cause of Will’s PTSD is never
explained. Neither is the life Will
and Tom led before the death of Tom’s wife.
There is no transitional phase in the story arc. While the script attempts to reveal Will’s
thoughts behind his chosen lifestyle, it does so poorly; and does nothing to
reveal Tom’s emotional shift from her father.
|
STARS
|
Ben Foster. Thomasin
Harcourt McKenzie.
|
TECH FOLKS:
|
Screenplay: Debra
Granik & Anne Rosellini.
Cinematography:
Martin McDonough
Editor: Jane Rizzo
Director: Debra
Granik
|
PLOT:
|
LEAVE NO
TRACE is written by Debra Granik & Anne Rosellini, based on the
novel “My Abandonment” by Peter
Rock. Will (Ben Foster) and his teenage daughter, Tom (Thomasin
Harcourt McKenzie), live off the grid for years in the forests of Portland,
Oregon. When park rangers discover their lifestyle, both are put into social
services. One can adapt, the other cannot, resulting in a clash between
father and daughter.
|
ACTING
Grade D
|
Ben Foster is an amazing actor. His talents here are wasted, as the
material he works with is lame.
Outside of looking gloomy, which apparently all men do in woman
directed films, he is offered no opportunity to display his talents.
Young Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie (one of the dreaded
three-named people) shuffles through her role like an ingénue with dirty
fingernails.
|
SCRIPT
Grade F
|
The
story is one of conforming to society.
The authoritarian figures in the film are presented as purveyors of
good, though they are destroying the remnants of a family. Much of the father-daughter relationship is
unexplained, making the final decision lame.
|
TECHNICAL:
Grade C
|
There is nothing in this film of note on the technical
side. Everyone performs in yeoman
style.
|
RECOMMENDATIONS:
|
I would suggest you avoid this film at all costs. It is slow and uninteresting. It’s not that the subject matter is feeble,
it is just presented poorly. This
would only appeal to staunch feminists who despise the concept of a single
man raising a daughter.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment